Disney Fights to Dismiss Doctor’s Allergy Death Lawsuit Over a Disney+ Subscription
Jeffrey Piccolo is battling Disney in a court case over his late wife’s death after a meal at Disney Springs. His wife, Kanokporn Tangsuan, died from anaphylaxis following their dinner at Raglan Road Irish Pub and Restaurant. She had told the staff about her severe nut and dairy allergies. Despite her precautions, she had a fatal allergic reaction.
Piccolo, serving as the personal representative for Tangsuan’s estate, has filed a lawsuit claiming more than $50,000 for wrongful death. This includes mental anguish, lost income, and funeral costs.
Disney is pushing back hard according to New York Post. They want the lawsuit dismissed, pointing to a Disney+ subscription Piccolo signed up for in 2019. According to Disney, when he subscribed, he agreed to settle disputes through arbitration—not in court. They claim this applies even now, to this wrongful death case. Disney’s argument extends to another agreement Piccolo made when he purchased Epcot tickets using the ‘My Disney Experience’ app.
Lawyers for Piccolo think Disney’s move is out of line. They argue that it’s completely unreasonable to link a streaming service agreement to a wrongful death claim. They’re fighting to keep the case in court, stating the idea that such a term could block a jury trial for any Disney-related incident is unfair.
Public response has been fiery. Beau DeMayo called the situation ‘disgraceful,’ while John LeFevre bluntly criticized Disney. Rob Freund, a legal expert, questioned the feasibility of Disney’s defense, hinting it’s a long shot.
This legal tussle touches on something bigger—how much power service agreements might have over our rights. It’s odd to think that signing up for a streaming trial could influence such a serious legal right as a trial by jury. Yet, here we are. The question is, do these terms hold up in court when they affect such critical and personal issues?
We often scroll through terms of service and agree without thinking. This case might make us pause and consider the fine print a bit more closely. How many other rights do we sign away without knowing?
Have something to add? Let us know in the comments below!