Top 10 Superman Actors Ranked from Worst to Best by DC Fans


Who’s the best Superman of all time? It’s a hot topic among us, the fans, as we debate who truly nailed the character of Clark Kent and his heroic alter ego. From animated voices to iconic live-action performances, each actor brought something unique to the cape. Let’s dive into the rankings as voted by DC fans, and see who soared above the rest!

10. Nolan North

Nolan North may be more renowned for his voice acting in video games, but he’s also left his mark on the Superman legacy. Through various Lego DC Comics movies and the animated series ‘Young Justice’, North’s portrayal of Superman has captivated a younger audience, bringing a vibrant energy to the character that resonates well beyond the screen.

9. Dean Cain

Dean Cain brought a charming and relatable version of Superman to life in ‘Lois & Clark: The New Adventures of Superman’. His performance from 1993 to 1997 showcased a more humanized Clark Kent, emphasizing his romantic and journalistic pursuits, which won the hearts of many fans.

8. George Newbern

Known primarily for his role in ‘Justice League’ and its sequel series ‘Justice League Unlimited’, George Newbern’s voice gave Superman a calm and authoritative presence. His tenure as the Man of Steel spanned numerous animated films and series, cementing his place as a beloved figure in the DC animated universe.

7. George Reeves

George Reeves is one of the original faces of Superman, starring in ‘Adventures of Superman’ from 1952 to 1958. His portrayal is often remembered for its straightforward, earnest approach, which set the standard for many superhero portrayals that followed.

6. Brandon Routh

Brandon Routh’s role in ‘Superman Returns’ (2006) was a homage to Christopher Reeve’s Superman, embodying the same noble and gentle characteristics. Although the film received mixed reviews, Routh’s performance was widely praised for its faithfulness to the spirit of Reeve’s interpretation.


Top 10 Batman Actors Ranked from Worst to Best by DC Fans

5. Tim Daly

Tim Daly voiced Superman in ‘Superman: The Animated Series’ and several animated films, bringing a definitive voice that many fans associate with the animated Man of Steel. His portrayal captured the hero’s moral compass and steadfast nature, making him a standout voice actor in the Superman roster.

4. Tom Welling

Tom Welling is best known for his long-running role as Clark Kent in ‘Smallville’, which explored the early years of Kent before he becomes Superman. Welling’s portrayal focused on Clark’s struggle with his identity and destiny, offering a deeper, more personal look at the character’s growth over ten seasons.

3. Tyler Hoechlin

Tyler Hoechlin currently stars as Superman in ‘Superman & Lois’, bringing a modern touch to the character. His portrayal balances the responsibilities of being a world-saving superhero with the everyday challenges of being a husband and father, adding new layers to the iconic character.

2. Henry Cavill

Henry Cavill brought a modern and physically imposing Superman to life in the DC Extended Universe films. His performances in movies like ‘Man of Steel’ and ‘Justice League’ have redefined the character for a new generation, blending vulnerability with immense power.

1. Christopher Reeve

Christopher Reeve is often regarded as the definitive Superman for his iconic portrayal that began with ‘Superman’ (1978) and spanned three sequels. His ability to embody both Superman’s heroism and Clark Kent’s clumsiness with charm and sincerity has made him a timeless favorite among fans and critics alike.

Ranked by DC fans on Ranker

Similar Posts

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments